The Digital Signage Insider

Project Scope for your Interactive Kiosks and Digital Signs: Avoid Feature Creep!

Published on: 0000-00-00

I'd like to get back to some of the items remaining on WireSpring's guide to avoiding the Top 13 Deployment Mistakes, and specifically the one that I'll focus on today is:

#4: Cramming Too Many Features into Version 1.0

It used to be that this was primarily a problem for interactive kiosk projects, however as more people add complex display software and interactive elements into their digital signage systems, it becomes increasingly relevant there as well.  We've all heard the urban legend that 70% of technology projects fail (actually, depending on who is telling the story, it's 70% of IT projects, or 70% of computer projects, or 70% of software projects, but you get the point).  Here's an article about it from InfoWorld, which is funny, because they also wrote another article about how that isn't in fact the case, but I digress...  To be more specific, some large number of technology projects (but I would venture to say it also applies to projects that have nothing to do with tech as well) run into problems because their scope is never clearly defined.  Project scope, as it is simply and succinctly described in Six Sigma terms, is the "defined and specific project beginning and end points. The more specific the details (what's in-scope and what's out of scope, the less a project may experience 'scope creep')."  It sounds obvious, but a huge number of companies fail to adequately scope their projects before getting started with planning, sourcing, and the rest of it.  That's why the very first thing that we do with new customers is to go over their project and see if there is a clear definition of its purpose, intent and limitations.  Here are some of the questions that we typically ask.  You'll note that while some of them are technical in nature, many have to do with the business side of things:
  • What is the overall purpose of the network?  Should it be providing customer service, lowering manpower costs, driving sales, or something else?
  • What is the minimum amount of functionality needed to prove your business model?
  • For each additional feature to be added (or implemented), what are the expected returns?
  • For each additional feature that has already been added, did you get the returns that you were expecting?
  • Is the primary focus of this project the trial deployment or the full system rollout?
  • Has funding for the project been secured, or is it dependent upon the success of an initial trial?
  • How will the network produce a return on investment?  Will it be a transactional system (autonomous revenue generation), advertising supported, or something else?
  • Is the purpose of the trial to test technology, customer comfort levels, receptiveness to different types of content, or something else?
  • Can the network be rolled out in phases, or must it all be done at once?
  • Can your software be upgraded in phases (which may necessitate the re-training of on-site staff), or does all of the functionality need to be deployed at once?
  • Will you be responsible for the entire network end-to-end (including network connectivity, power, etc.), or just the kiosk and/or digital signage hardware?
  • Has this project been requested by a client or potential client, or are you designing it ahead of time in hopes of selling it as a product or service offering?
  • What things are you taking for your assumptions?  For example, are you counting on signing some number of advertisers before you ever deploy your system?  Do you need to have some number of deployment venues before your funding comes through?
Another useful trick for trying to describe how your kiosk or signage business will work is to actually draw out the relationships of all of the people (or groups) that you will need to make the project a success.  I'm not talking about getting into ultra-complex UML use case diagrams or anything like that (although you can, if you're comfortable with that sort of thing).  Even a quick, back-of-the-envelope sketch of the different parties involved and how they interact will help you to mentally organize the different aspects of your projects, and the different relationships that will need to be cultivated and managed.

Finally, you might want to consider putting together a formal scope document.  These often take the form of an extended outline describing all of the parts of your system, and answering at least most of the questions listed above.  While not typically used as legal documents, project scope documents can be thought of as a "contract" between all of the different parties involved, and if done properly, can help to highlight the strengths and weaknesses of your organization as your network gets deployed.


+1 # Ornette E. Barrett 2008-09-05 09:48
I am resident in Warri, Southern Nigeria, with limited but growing knowledge of kiosks and am extremely passionate about starting a kiosk deployment/roll out company that will place multi media/multi function kiosks in as many locations as possible. I am looking for the right people and companies to work with to cost effectively design, produce and place these kiosks. The kiosk themselves will take passport photos, print various sizes of photos, calendars, greeting cards, posters, documents and stickers. They will also disburse various tickets (airline,concert,lottery,etc), telephone airtime, loyalty cards, etc. They will also be used for gaming, information, digital signage, creation of photo and music CDs and DVDs, downloading of ringtones and games, internet access and bill payment. They will work with most storage media and accept a wide range of payment options, cash inclusive. They may even include ATM functions. If you believe that this is achieveable and would like to work with me to make this happen, please contact me on 009-234-7055727203 or email with subject heading "we can make it happen".
+1 # Bill Gerba 2008-09-08 13:45
Hi Ornette, One thing I noticed just in your comment is that your project scope doesn't seem to be as well-defined as it might be. For example, putting CD/DVD burning or rental in the same machine as an ATM doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Most people who want to burn a CD probably don't want to take out money, and vice-versa. My advice would be to pick the one or two core applications that have the greatest chance of generating revenue, and focus on those! -Bill

Subscribe to the Digital Signage Insider RSS feed

Looking for more articles and research? Our newest articles can always be found at Digital Signage Insider, but there are hundreds of additional research articles in our historical articles archive.

You may also be interested in M2M Insider: our blog about M2M and the Internet of Things.